Are you doing Phase 2 wrong?


Hey there,

Phase 2 doesn’t get the credit it deserves.

At least, not in the way it’s commonly taught as a rigid checklist.

I often see clinicians treat Preparation as a brief pitstop (in other words, a necessary chore to “get through” before Phase 4 begins). But in my clinical experience, I’ve seen time and time again how rushing through resourcing is actually the fastest way to stall a client's progress.

That’s why today, I’d like to explore what it takes to build a solid foundation so you never have to lose another session to unexpected crisis management.

Imagine a client who comes in with a clear trauma history.

You take a thorough history, install a Calm Place and a Container, check the boxes, and move into reprocessing within a few sessions.

You picked an easy starting point (lower SUDs), and the first session goes okay.

The second one starts okay too, but about ten minutes in, your client's activation spikes higher than expected. They start to dissociate. You try to bring them back with the Calm Place, but it doesn't land. You spend the rest of the session trying to help them regulate instead of EMDR.

They leave shaky.

They email you twice during the week.

Then the next session, they're guarded, less willing to engage, and you catch yourself doubting whether EMDR is even the right fit for this client.

Most of us have run into a version of this, including myself. It’s tempting to attribute it to the client (i.e. they’re too complex, too dissociative, not ready, etc) when often what actually happened is they were under-resourced going into the work.

When the nervous system runs out of runway like this, the processing loop snaps shut. To understand why, we have to look back at the core physiology of the AIP model.


Without the Window, There’s No Processing

We can't bypass physiology.

Reprocessing requires the client to stay within their window of tolerance long enough for adaptive information processing to occur.

If they fall into hyperarousal, processing stops and they flood. Or if they fall into hypoarousal, processing stops and they dissociate or shut down.

Either way, the AIP system can't do its job.

Resourcing, then, is what gives clients the capacity to stay within that window. Not just during the initial moments of activation, but throughout an entire reprocessing session, between sessions, across multiple sessions, and over the longer arc of treatment.

A client with a narrow window and limited resources isn't going to process complex trauma effectively, and it has nothing to do with whether the protocol works.

When we under-resource in Phase 2 and then rush to Phase 4, we're essentially asking a client to do work their nervous system isn't equipped for yet (and then we wonder why they're getting stuck… as if the problem is the client and not the prep!)


When Memory Networks Spill Over the Session Timer

This physiological capacity becomes even more critical when we realize that memory networks rarely follow our session timers. Reprocessing surfaces material that often can't be fully processed in a single session.

You target one memory, and three others come up. You start working on a recent trigger and end up in childhood material you weren't expecting. The brain associates (or reverberates), and you can't always predict what's going to surface.

Without strong containment and grounding resources, clients leave session carrying that surfaced material into their week. Which while expected to some degree, can become incredibly destabilizing without the proper guardrails.

That's why adequate preparation and giving clients time to develop familiarity and confidence in the skills you teach them, is so important.

For one, it's how clients learn to set down activated material between sessions so they can keep functioning in their lives. It also gives your clients an opportunity to learn how to manage partial processing.

The therapists I've spoken with who've had clients spiral between sessions almost always identify, in retrospect, that the client didn't have adequate preparation in place.


Moving Beyond In-Session Regulation

But containment is only half the battle.

If a client can only hold it together by locking things away until their next appointment, they remain trapped in a fragile cycle.

Clients who develop strong stabilization skills can use those skills outside of session. They can ground themselves when triggered at work, regulate when activated by a relationship moment, or pull themselves back from dissociation when it starts to creep in.

Without those skills, clients are dependent on the next session to feel okay. Every difficult moment is something to bring to therapy, and while there's nothing wrong with bringing material to therapy, clients who can only regulate in session are essentially white-knuckling their way through the week and surviving on borrowed regulation.

When that happens, therapy becomes a weekly cleanup operation.

We find ourselves constantly putting out the fires of the last seven days instead of moving forward into deep, transformative reprocessing.


The Attachment Message Behind Slow Pacing

There's something else worth noting that happens during Phase 2. Something that directly impacts your Phase 4 outcomes but doesn't get talked about enough:

Preparation is a profound relational intervention.

When you spend time helping a client identify resources, install them carefully, troubleshoot when they don't land, and tailor them to that specific person's needs, you're communicating neuroceptive safety.

You're showing them that you take their stability seriously. That you're not going to rush them into something they're not ready for, and that you understand their nervous system needs to come along on this journey.

This slow, collaborative pacing builds an unshakeable therapeutic alliance.

Clients who feel rushed through Phase 2 often don't fully trust the process by the time you get to Phase 4. They're more guarded, less willing to drop into difficult material, more likely to question whether they're safe in the work.

On the other hand, clients who feel attended to during Phase 2 come into reprocessing with a different posture. They know you've been careful with them, and trust you'll continue to be.

That trust is what allows them to bring their full nervous system into the work.


Slowing Down to Speed Up

Phase 2 is the foundation everything else sits on.

How well you resource is going to shape how well you reprocess, how safe your client is between sessions, and how well their gains hold once treatment ends.

That doesn't mean spending months in Phase 2 with every client. Some clients come in already well-resourced. Others need significantly more time. The point is to resource adequately, and to build the specific toolkit your client needs to fully tolerate the dual awareness required for deep healing.

Have you ever had a case where you went back and strengthened Phase 2 partway through treatment?

What happened when you did?

Until next time,
Chris


Thanks for reading Helicon's EMDR Therapist Weekly, where we aim to provide a weekly dose of insights, tools, and opportunities for EMDR therapists; designed to support your growth, sharpen your practice, and connect you with what's next.


If you're not already subscribed, subscribe here. You can also click here to learn about what Helicon is building, or apply to join the waitlist for early access to the platform, if you're an EMDR provider and want to connect with others on the same path.

Disclaimer: The information contained in this article is for informational purposes only. This is not legal or clinical advice and we make no guarantees about the outcomes or results from information shared in this document. Proceed at your own risk and discretion.

EMDR Therapist Weekly

A weekly dose of insights, tools, and opportunities for EMDR therapists; designed to support your growth, sharpen your practice, and connect you with what's next.

Read more from EMDR Therapist Weekly
Interlocking hexagonal basalt columns form a natural rock wall.

The EMDR Therapist Weekly aims to provide a weekly dose of insights, tools, and opportunities for EMDR therapists; designed to support your growth, sharpen your practice, and connect you with what's next. To achieve this, we occasionally invite subject matter experts as guest writers. I'm excited to introduce another guest writer this week: Dr. Amber Quaranta-Leech, LPC-S Dr. Quaranta-Leech is a Licensed Professional Counselor and Supervisor, EMDRIA Approved Consultant and Trainer, and COO of...

A small waterfall cascades over rocks into a clear pool.

Hey there, Have you ever run into a client who struggles to access or benefit from a calming resource the way the protocol intended? You walk them through the setup, they follow along, and they tell you they have an image, but something is missing. The felt sense isn't there, the imagery feels flat, or they return the next week and admit that when panic hit mid-week, the tool "just didn't work." If you've practiced EMDR for any length of time, you've probably hit this wall before. Container...

Rocky tide pools along a forested coastline.

Hey there, Here's a scenario that's probably familiar: A new client sits down across from you. They've been referred for trauma. They've done some research, read a few articles online, and now they're looking at you with that mix of curiosity and skepticism that's become really common with EMDR. "So... we're going to move my eyes back and forth? And that's supposed to help me with what happened to me?" You've answered this question a hundred times. Or the question from a counseling colleague...