|
October 1997. Hurricane Pauline had just torn along Mexico’s Pacific coast and left the Acapulco area with hundreds of thousands of people displaced. Many of them were children. Among the clinicians who showed up to help in the aftermath were Lucina Artigas and Ignacio Jarero. They had only recently been introduced to EMDR, and now they faced a problem no basic training prepares you for: far more traumatized kids than therapists, and no realistic way to see each child individually. So like any good EMDR therapist, they improvised. According to the account preserved in the Francine Shapiro Library, there weren’t even pencils or paper when they started working with the children. Instead, Artigas had the children think about the worst part of the hurricane and draw it in the sand with their fingers. The children then crossed their arms and tapped their shoulders themselves, alternating left and right. That self-administered bilateral tapping became the Butterfly Hug, which EMDRIA recognized with its Creative Innovation Award in 2000. The group structure built around it became the EMDR Integrative Group Treatment Protocol, or EMDR-IGTP. Why am I telling this story? Because it challenges one of the most deeply ingrained assumptions about EMDR. Many of us learned the standard protocol for one client and one clinician, so processing trauma with twelve or twenty people at once might sound somewhere between impractical and reckless. Yet group EMDR was born out of stark necessity, and decades later, it has evolved into a set of protocols with a growing body of research behind them. Let’s start with how these protocols work. What group EMDR looks like in practiceEven in group protocols, the 8 phases themselves don’t change. However, unlike individual EMDR, participants don’t share their trauma details out loud. Each person works privately with their own drawing or worksheet, and bilateral stimulation is self-administered, usually through the Butterfly Hug or alternating taps. Meanwhile, the clinicians hold the container, monitor the room for over-arousal, and step in when someone needs more support. That’s the basic shape of IGTP, the first widely used group protocol. The second major group protocol came later. In 2013, Elan Shapiro introduced the Group Traumatic Episode Protocol (G-TEP), adapted from the Recent Traumatic Episode Protocol they developed with Brurit Laub. G-TEP uses a structured worksheet and is built around the idea of a “trauma episode”: the original event plus the aftermath that followed it, which hasn’t yet been consolidated into a settled memory. That episode-based framing makes it especially useful for people who are still living through the consequences of a crisis, like refugees or frontline workers. What the research shows about group EMDRThe early studies on IGTP were small and uncontrolled, which is common for interventions developed in disaster zones. Jarero, Artigas, and colleagues used IGTP with 16 bereaved children after a human-caused disaster in the Mexican state of Coahuila in 2006. The report published in 2008 showed trauma symptoms dropped significantly and held at a three-month follow-up. A 2010 study used IGTP over three consecutive days with 20 adults in a Central American country during an ongoing geopolitical crisis, and the gains held at 14 weeks even though the crisis hadn’t ended. Stronger evidence for group EMDR came with randomized designs. In a 2018 RCT published in Frontiers in Psychology, Yurtsever and colleagues delivered G-TEP to Syrian refugees living in a camp. Every participant in the study met criteria for PTSD at the start. After two sessions over three days, about 61% of the G-TEP group no longer met criteria, and that was held at a four-week follow-up. In the control group, about 10% no longer met criteria. Depression symptoms dropped too, but only in the treatment group. More recently, Derek Farrell and colleagues ran an RCT of G-TEP delivered over video to frontline health, emergency, and social care workers during COVID-19, with 85 participants completing the study. They found a large effect on trauma symptoms and no effect on moral injury, a good reminder that memory-focused processing has limits. And of course there’s the Ukraine study that was shared by the author in a previous guest post for our newsletter, which reported the primary finding was a statistically significant reduction in PTSD symptoms from pretest to six-week follow-up in the treatment group. For the broader picture, a 2021 systematic review pulled together 22 studies with 1,739 participants across IGTP, G-TEP, and related protocols. The authors concluded that group EMDR may reduce PTSD, depression, and anxiety. They also noted that many of the studies lacked control groups and that more rigorous trials are needed. So what does all of this mean if you’re working in a private practice or agency, far from any disaster zone? Where group EMDR fits in everyday practiceMost of us will likely never deploy to a hurricane zone, but EMDR group protocols (like IGTP and G-TEP) show up well outside disaster response too. They’ve been studied with healthcare staff and frontline workers during the pandemic, including over video, and with people living through ongoing crises. They’re also used in cancer support settings, where Jarero and colleagues have published on adapting IGTP for patients living with ongoing medical stress. That said, I wouldn’t recommend just reading a few articles and trying IGTP or G-TEP with your next group. This is because group protocols assume you already have a solid command of the standard protocol, and add demands of their own like:
This added complexity is why beyond finding colleagues to team up with, I’d recommend two things before you run your first group: The first is protocol-specific training. IGTP and G-TEP each have their own, generally taught by the developers or trainers they’ve authorized, and they typically aren’t part of basic EMDR training. The second is consultation. Running a group for the first time usually raises questions that are hard to anticipate from a manual (like what to do when one participant becomes overwhelmed while the rest of the group is still processing). That’s why I recommend having someone experienced with facilitating group protocols who can help you think through screening decisions and debrief each session afterward. If you’re looking for a consultant who’s run groups before, Helicon lets you browse consultants by clinical specialty and approach so you can more easily find someone with group or early-intervention experience. It won’t train you in IGTP or G-TEP, but it can shorten your search (and has curated links to recommended training). Have you used IGTP or G-TEP in your practice, or seen them used in your community? Hit reply and let me know what you’ve observed. Until next time, Thanks for reading Helicon's EMDR Therapist Weekly, where we aim to provide a weekly dose of insights, tools, and opportunities for EMDR therapists; designed to support your growth, sharpen your practice, and connect you with what's next. If you're not already subscribed, subscribe here. You can also click here to learn about what Helicon is building, or sign up to be notified when the platform is publicly available, if you're an EMDR provider and want to connect with others on the same path. Disclaimer: The information contained in this article is for informational purposes only. This is not legal or clinical advice and we make no guarantees about the outcomes or results from information shared in this document. Proceed at your own risk and discretion. |
A weekly dose of insights, tools, and opportunities for EMDR therapists; designed to support your growth, sharpen your practice, and connect you with what's next.
Hey there, Has a client ever told you they're microdosing? Or that they're planning a psilocybin retreat, or starting ketamine treatment? Psychedelic use is coming up a lot more often during sessions, leaving many EMDR therapists unsure of their role. We're not prescribing or providing these substances, but clients are using them anyway and bringing those experiences back into our offices. That’s why this week, I wanted to look at what the research says about macro-doses and micro-doses, and...
Hey there, Have you ever had someone tell you EMDR is “pseudoscience”? Maybe it was a colleague in case consultation, or a professor back in grad school. Or maybe it was a client who read something online the night before their first session, worried they were signing up for something that doesn't work. How did it make you feel? Defensive? There are a number of criticisms that come up again and again, and some of them have a grain of truth. So this week I want to walk through the most common...
Hey there, In case you missed it, we recently sent out the first invitations to join Helicon. What’s Helicon? In short, it’s a platform built specifically for EMDR therapists. Members can search our private consultant directory, track consultation hours alongside their consultant, find guides and partner discounts, access private virtual events with subject matter experts, and connect with other EMDR therapists in our private Signal group. Now that the first invites have gone out, I wanted to...